Paul's words forbidding women to "teach" have raised questions at all times. Indeed: God can give a certain special gift to both a man and a woman, and the experience of communion with God experienced by women is often brighter and deeper than that of men. Meanwhile, the apostle is saying...
Paul's words forbidding women to "teach" have raised questions at all times. Indeed: God can give a certain special gift to both a man and a woman, and the experience of communion with God experienced by women is often brighter and deeper than that of men. Meanwhile, the apostle is not saying at all that a woman should remain silent about her experience of communion with God or the feelings associated with it. The point is that women should not become teachers in the sense that this word was understood in the early Christian Church.
Teaching in those times was primarily a ministry associated with the experience of realizing and comprehending the inner Torah and with teaching this path to others. Actually, the rabbi teachers played the same role in traditional synagogues. In Christian synagogues (and in those times the Church existed precisely in the form of a Christian synagogue), it was no longer just about the experience of the inner Torah, but also about the experience of a person's becoming in Christ as a living Torah and, in this sense, about the experience of a person's assimilation to Christ as a disciple to the Teacher. This implied a very intensive spiritual life and a very strenuous ascetic work—not in the sense, of course, of the mortification of the flesh, as asceticism is often understood today, but in the sense of spiritually building one's life (both internal and external) and forming within oneself that spiritual core without which there is no point in talking about the inner Torah and the becoming of a person in Christ.
Such a path is very difficult in itself: it requires from a person a serious, often extreme tension of physical and especially mental forces. And if one is also to teach and instruct others, moreover in the way it should be done, and every time, in the process of any communication, whether with one person or with many, maintaining the state that will allow the words not to be spiritually empty, the tension can sometimes become simply overwhelming. Women are more enduring than men in a situation of prolonged and constant strain, but under conditions of short-term stress they, as a rule, still fall short of them. Meanwhile, in the ministry of a teacher there are many such moments; his whole life, in a certain sense, consists mainly of constant stresses, although externally it may sometimes seem more or less measured. Such a regime is more likely to prove unbearable for a woman than for a man, which means that a serious psychological breakdown can be more likely expected from her if she wants to be a real teacher, and not just in name.
An alternative (since the instinct of self-preservation has not been canceled by anyone) can easily become the profanation of the ministry, when a person remains a teacher externally, having internally ceased to be one—which is no better, and in many ways even worse than a breakdown. Of course, a man carrying out the ministry of a teacher is not immune from either, but he still has a better chance of a successful outcome, which, apparently, is what guides the apostle when he forbids women to carry out the ministry of teachers in the Church.
2
2:12 To usurp authority over the man - By public teaching.